A court reporter in your family law case can be a crucial part of establishing a clear and irrefutable record of what happens at a court hearing or some other official proceeding, like a deposition in a divorce case. In the past, most courts hired official court reporters to work in the courtroom and take down all the proceedings at any trial or hearing. Currently, though, most courts put the responsibility on the parties to choose to have a court reporter at in your family law and other civil law hearings. People going through a divorce and custody case must decide whether it’s worth the expense and trouble of arranging for a court reporter for a hearing or deposition. Experts recommend that having a court reporter in your divorce or custody case is a good idea for a few important reasons.
Why Do You Need A Court Reporter In A Family Law Case?
A court reporter has the responsibility and the ability to record a hearing, trial, or deposition in full. Every word that is spoken, as well as all pauses, evasions, silence in response to direct questions, and even all the verbal hesitations such as sounds like “uh…” or “hm…” or “um…” are recorded in a verbatim record that will get transcribed and typed up into a written account of the proceeding. This record can be critical if one party needs to appeal a court decision or even to hold a witness to account for what they said previously in sworn testimony.
In most modern civil cases in Oklahoma, the court doesn’t hire or provide a court reporter automatically as a matter of course, so it is the party’s responsibility to have a reporter present if they want one. If a court reporter isn’t at the hearing, there won’t be a full record of everything said and done on that occasion. This can be a weak spot if you or your attorney need to refer to exactly what everyone at the hearing said, asked, responded, and even avoided saying.
Avoid Excessive Informality At Family Law Hearings
Some lawyers note that hearings and proceedings that aren’t officially recorded by a court reporter may become somewhat informal as judges and attorneys realize that there isn’t a verbatim record of everything being said. Objections may be treated lightly, or arguments may become more personal or heated if there isn’t a formal record. Family law proceedings like divorce and custody matters, especially, often involve heated emotions and high stakes that can benefit from being documented for future reference.
Temporary orders are typically not subject to appeal, so a record isn’t required for the appeal court, but it can be very helpful to have a clear statement of everything that happened and what all the parties, lawyers, and judges said at the hearing for the final trial or hearing on a final order. With a transcript that a court reporter provides, your lawyer can refer to what was said and remind witnesses and other lawyers of what they said at the previous hearing.
Appealing A Family Law Ruling in Oklahoma
When considering an appeal of a family law judge’s ruling, it is important to note that the grounds for appeal can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the specific circumstances of the case. The order being appealed must be a final order. As mentioned above, temporary orders or other interlocutory orders are not appealable. An example includes a temporary order for child custody or child support. The basis for an appeal is limited and must be shown in the court reporters record of the proceeding. Here are some common grounds used to appeal a final order in Oklahoma family court:
- Legal Errors: An appeal may be warranted if the judge made a significant legal error, such as misinterpreting or misapplying the law. For example, if the judge applied an incorrect legal standard or failed to consider relevant legal principles, it could provide grounds for an appeal.
- Procedural Errors: If there were procedural irregularities or errors during the court proceedings that may have affected the outcome of the case, such as the denial of the right to present evidence or improper conduct by the judge, it could be a basis for appeal. Its not enough to point out a procedural error by itself. Rather, the procedural error must have materially impacted the final order.
- Abuse of Discretion: This is a basis sited in most final orders in family court. An appellate court may overturn a judge’s ruling if it determines that the judge abused their discretion in making a particular decision. This typically requires showing that the judge’s decision was arbitrary, unreasonable, or not supported by the facts or the law. In family law courts the Judge is given broad discretion and the claimed abuse must be egregious.
- Factual Errors: While appeals generally focus on legal errors rather than factual disputes, if the judge’s findings of fact are clearly unsupported by the evidence presented during the trial, it may be possible to appeal on the basis of factual errors.
- Violation of Constitutional Rights: If a party’s constitutional rights were violated during the proceedings, such as a denial of due process, freedom of speech, or equal protection like fathers rights, it could serve as a basis for appeal.
- Fraud or Misconduct: If there is evidence of fraud or misconduct by the opposing party or their legal counsel that influenced the judge’s decision, it may be possible to appeal based on these grounds. This cant be speculation of fraud and misconduct by the opposing party. There must be explicit evidence and it must be based on direct and articulable evidence. The fraud or misconduct must be the actual cause of the order that you are trying to appeal.
Custody rulings in family court are typically not subject to appeal just because a party disagrees with the ruling. A party must prove that the court made an error of law or fact in deciding the matter. A court reporter’s verbatim record of all that was said at the hearing can be critical in attempting to challenge a court’s custody ruling.
Additional Family Law Articles From Our Tulsa Lawyers Blog
Tulsa Family and Custody Attorney Near You
A court reporter In your family law case is important to preserving testimony and other evidence. Emotions run high in divorce and custody proceedings and things happen that need to be on the record. People can say things that cross the line into unacceptable territory. The experienced attorneys at Kania Law Office understand what is required to get the best result in your legal matter. Call 918-743-2233 or contact us online for more information and to schedule a consultation.
Tulsa's Local Family & Divorce Lawyers
Are you looking for Tulsa attorneys who will fight aggressively for you? Our team of family & divorce attorneys have the experience needed in Oklahoma law to secure the outcome you deserve.