Understanding The Difference Between Dismissal With and Without Prejudice in Oklahoma

The news is full of stories related to criminal cases and there dismissal with and without prejudice. When a legal case is dismissed, it can be dismissed either with prejudice or without prejudice—two terms that have significant legal consequences. This incudes cases filed in both criminal and civil court. If you are involved in a criminal defense or civil case in Oklahoma, understanding the Difference Between Dismissal With and Without Prejudice helps you understand how to go forward after the case is done.

Dismissal With Prejudice in Criminal Defense

In the context of a criminal case the difference between the two is critical. A case that is dismissed with prejudice is closed forever. This means that the prosecutor in Oklahoma cannot refile the same case in the future. A judge may dismiss a case with prejudice for several reasons, including:

• Lack of evidence or legal merit
• Violation of procedural rules
• Resolution through settlement
• Constitutional or legal violations that bar further prosecution

For example, in a criminal case, if the prosecution engages in misconduct—such as withholding valuable evidence. Or maybe they brought a criminal case for the purpose of harassment—the judge may dismiss the charges with prejudice. The judge might do this on their own motion or at the request of the State or the defendant. If the case is dismissed without prejudice this prevents the State from refiling the same case later. In a civil case, if a judge finds that a plaintiff’s claims are completely without merit, they may dismiss the lawsuit with prejudice. This is done to prevent the defendant from facing repeated litigation over the same issue. In a civil case its not uncommon for this kind of dismissal to include attorneys fees or other action if the case is found to be frivolous or filed for harassment.

Dismissal Without Prejudice

A case dismissed without prejudice allows the plaintiff or prosecution to refile the case in the future. This type of dismissal often occurs when there is a procedural issue. It may also happen when the plaintiff/prosecution needs more time to gather evidence. Common reasons for dismissing a case without prejudice include:

• The plaintiff or prosecution voluntarily withdraws the case
• The court finds a minor procedural error, such as improper service of process
• The prosecution needs additional evidence to move forward with charges

For instance, if a prosecutor dismisses a criminal case without prejudice, they may do so because key witnesses are unavailable. But in this case they intend to refile the charges later when those witnesses are available. In a civil lawsuit, if a plaintiff realizes they filed their case incorrectly, they may voluntarily dismiss it without prejudice and refile it later with the correct legal arguments.

Implications of Each Type of Dismissal

• With Prejudice: The case is closed permanently, and the plaintiff/prosecution cannot bring the same claim or charges again.
• Without Prejudice: The case is temporarily closed, but the plaintiff/prosecution may refile the case later, subject to any applicable statutes of limitations.

What Should You Do If Your Case Is Dismissed?

If your criminal case is dismissed with prejudice, you can move forward without fear of facing the same charges again. If it is dismissed without prejudice, you have the pressure of potential criminal charges being brought against you for the same charge in the future. It can also impact any plea deals that are on the table.

On the other hand, If you in the middle of civil litigation that is being dismissed how its dismissed will impact your rights in the future. Once again, depending on the facts of the case the Difference Between Dismissal With and Without Prejudice can impact your rights going forward.

Checkout Our Tulsa Lawyers Blog For More Legal Information

Tulsa Oklahoma Criminal Defense You Can Count On

If you are involved in either a civil or criminal defense case its important to understand the Difference Between Dismissal With and Without Prejudice. Understanding this key difference might matter in the way the case is settled. Before you proceed in this kind of case get a free consultation with a Tulsa attorney from the Kania Law Office by calling 918.743.2233. Or you can follow this link to ask a free online legal question.